Reddit has taken significant action against two of its communities after Elon Musk, owner of X, alleged that user comments targeting his employees were illegal. The platform temporarily banned the subreddit r/WhitePeopleTwitter for 72 hours and permanently removed r/IsElonDeadYet following heated discussions that escalated into threats against members of the Musk-led Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE).
The Controversy Unfolds
The dispute began when users on r/WhitePeopleTwitter, a subreddit known for sharing humorous content from X (formerly Twitter), made comments calling for violence against DOGE staff. These remarks were in response to reports suggesting that certain DOGE employees had access to sensitive personal data of millions of Americans.
Musk, who has frequently positioned himself as a staunch advocate of free speech, reacted strongly to the comments. He took to X to denounce the threats, stating, “They have broken the law.” Following this statement, Reddit swiftly took action, issuing a temporary ban on the subreddit. BBC News reported that the subreddit’s ban was a direct consequence of Musk’s public outcry.
Reddit’s Response and Community Backlash
While Reddit did not comment on this specific incident, the platform released a general statement reinforcing its policies. “Debate and dissent are welcome on Reddit – threats and doxing are not,” it read. The move sparked outrage among some users, who accused Reddit of selectively enforcing its policies based on external pressure.
Elon Musk’s actions drew mixed reactions. Imran Ahmed, director of the Centre for Countering Digital Hate (CCDH), criticized Musk’s stance, calling it hypocritical. “It’s always one rule for Elon and another for everyone else,” he remarked. “Oh, he’s about freedom alright—the freedom to do whatever he wants, no matter the cost to people, their families, and the fundamentals of democracy.”
Musk had previously sued the CCDH in 2023, alleging that it unlawfully accessed X data to report a rise in hate speech on the platform. However, in 2024, a U.S. judge dismissed the case, further fueling debates over Musk’s interpretation of free speech.
Reddit Communities Protest Against Musk
Tensions between Musk and Reddit users had already been simmering, and this latest controversy only escalated the situation. Over 100 subreddits initiated a ban on sharing links to X in protest against Musk’s controversial arm gesture at a rally celebrating Donald Trump’s return to office. The billionaire was seen extending his arm straight out twice, thanking the crowd for “making it happen.” Critics, including historians, interpreted the gesture as a Nazi salute. Musk dismissed the claims, calling them “tired” and “dirty tricks.”
The protest led to some of Reddit’s largest communities, including r/NBA (15 million members), r/TwoXChromosomes (14 million members), and r/NFL (12 million members), enforcing a self-imposed ban on X links. Although Reddit clarified that there was no sitewide ban on X content, community moderators exercised their power to restrict content. Given Reddit’s reliance on unpaid moderators, the decision to block X links reflected growing discontent among the user base.
The Impact of the Ban on X’s Traffic and Engagement
The ban on X links could significantly impact the platform’s reach, particularly in communities that rely on real-time updates from sports teams, analysts, and journalists. Historically, subreddits like r/NBA and r/AEW have sourced some of their most popular posts from X.
For instance, two of the top posts on the NBA subreddit were direct screenshots from X, while three of the top ten posts on the AEW wrestling subreddit also originated from the platform. Similarly, gaming communities, including those for Animal Crossing and Kingdom Hearts, have consistently used X as a source of content. With these bans in place, engagement with X on Reddit is expected to decline, potentially affecting X’s overall traffic and advertising revenue.

Divided Opinions: Who Supports the Ban?
Many Reddit communities across different interests have joined the movement to block X content. Subreddits dedicated to sports teams like Liverpool, Celtic, and Tottenham Hotspur, as well as Formula 1 and American football, have all enacted the ban. Regional communities representing locations from New Jersey to South Korea have also followed suit.
In addition to sports and regional subreddits, the ban has extended to gaming communities such as those for Baldur’s Gate 3 and World of Warcraft, as well as pop culture hubs discussing RuPaul’s Drag Race and Disneyland. The movement continues to gain traction as more communities debate implementing similar restrictions.
However, not all subreddits are on board. The moderators of the Maine subreddit stated that they would refrain from banning X links as long as the state maintains official accounts there. Likewise, the British Columbia subreddit declared, “We’re not doing censorship here.”
Will the Ban Last?
While the ban has caused a significant stir, history suggests that Reddit protests often have limited longevity. In 2023, thousands of communities “went dark” in protest of Reddit’s policy changes, only for most to resume normal activity later. Similarly, some of Reddit’s largest communities once restricted all content to photos and videos of comedian John Oliver in response to platform-wide dissatisfaction. These protests eventually faded.
It remains to be seen whether the boycott of X content will endure or if it is merely another temporary expression of user frustration. What is certain, however, is that Musk’s leadership and decision-making continue to generate controversy, both within his own platform and across the wider digital landscape.
Reddit’s crackdown on communities following Musk’s legal concerns marks yet another chapter in the ongoing battle between social media platforms, their users, and the evolving interpretation of free speech. As Reddit users continue to push back against Musk’s influence, the landscape of online discourse is once again being reshaped by power struggles between tech giants and digital communities.