NASHVILLE, Tenn. — Canadiens frequent manager Kent Hughes, talking after securing the No. 5 decide within the NHL Draft Lottery in Might perchance merely, acknowledged there is a difference between drafting and team constructing. There are qualities the Canadiens be taught about for in gamers they draft, and those ought to peaceable, therefore, be prioritized over how a participant fits into the organizational depth chart.
On Wednesday night time, after taking appropriate-shot Austrian defenceman David Reinbacher with that No. 5 decide within the draft, Hughes talked about that if Reinbacher were a left-shot defenceman, they’ll even contain “cooled” on him, however the group lacks depth on the appropriate facet.
It is refined to reconcile both these two reputedly conflictual statements being made by the same man six weeks apart. If there is a difference between drafting and team constructing, then the Canadiens’ organizational depth on the appropriate facet of their defence ought to be irrelevant on draft night time. When supplied with that contradiction between what he acknowledged after the lottery and what he acknowledged a diminutive while earlier, Hughes pushed motivate.
“On our checklist, he became once appropriate there. We rate gamers by methodology of their means,” he acknowledged. “Being a appropriate-shot D, tiebreaker would saunter to the appropriate-shot D when when put next with a left-shot D. But when we felt there became once a bigger decide, we would contain taken him.”
In scouting, there shouldn’t in point of truth be any ties. Scouts spend your entire season staring at these kids, talking to teammates, coaches, parents, attempting to scour every ounce of data they’ll. Hughes acknowledged he watched Reinbacher on video all season and cherished his progression as the season went along taking part in in a high European men’s league. That they had scouts talk over with Kloten in Switzerland all season, no longer finest their head European scout, Christer Rockstrom, no longer finest their co-administrators of amateur scouting Slice Bobrov and Martin Lapointe, but additionally about a of their American scouts, staunch to make certain of what all people became once seeing.
One of those scouts requested Kloten GM Larry Mitchell upon arrival in February what would cease Reinbacher from taking part in within the NHL. Mitchell’s response became once that nothing will cease him from taking part in within the NHL.
“And then this particular scout watched about a practices and he watched about a games and we had a coffee the subsequent day,” Mitchell acknowledged, “and he acknowledged I 100 p.c consider what you urged me about a days within the past.”
This level of in-depth, in-person scouting is what the Canadiens lacked on Matvei Michkov, who went two picks later to the Philadelphia Flyers at No. 7. Hughes acknowledged that became once the fundamental crimson flag for them. It wasn’t his contract with SKA St. Petersburg, it wasn’t the geopolitical panorama. It became once that they hadn’t seen him play rather than on video, and video never tells your entire legend.
And the Canadiens weren’t by myself.
“We had some concerns,” acknowledged San Jose Sharks GM Mike Grier, who handed on Michkov at No. 4. “He’s a diverse talent on the ice, there’s no query about it. Gargantuan skilled, could perchance well well make things quite a lot of other gamers can’t. But there are some things that we weren’t happy with in an effort to intention finish any individual with the fourth decide.”
The Arizona Coyotes also handed on Michkov at No. 6, no longer to sign the Anaheim Geese and Columbus Blue Jackets selecting earlier than the Sharks.
Unique Flyers GM Daniel Brière didn’t saunter.
“We took a huge swing, but we hope that this appears to be like to be a dwelling speed,” he acknowledged. “Time will direct and it’s honest a diminutive early, but we in point of truth feel when he’s willing to reach, he could perchance well well also in point of truth be a difference maker. And that’s the likelihood that we were willing to intention finish, to wait honest a diminutive bit to confidently contain a difference maker on our palms.”
Correct as Hughes’ two feedback six weeks apart sounded conflicting, so make those two feedback from two NHL GMs acknowledged a diminutive while apart.
Drafting for want versus drafting the finest participant available is mostly supplied as being diametrically opposed. You’re both doing one or the different. But that’s no longer essentially correct.
A high-pairing appropriate-shot defenceman is a want all the plot in which thru the league because they’re uncommon. Groups will most regularly overpay in a commerce or in free company to gain one thanks to that scarcity. And teams will most regularly rep apart a top rate on drafting them out of the ordinary better than most public lists contain them going thanks to that very same scarcity. The Unique Jersey Devils did so staunch final year when they drafted Šimon Nemec with the No. 2 overall decide, the Detroit Red Wings did it in 2019 when they took Moritz Seider at No. 6 overall.
There is the theorem of positional label that is baked into the equation of simplest participant available.
And when Hughes acknowledged drafting and team constructing are no longer the same thing, I also specialise in that is rarely any longer correct. Groups always be taught about to contain organizational holes, even on the quit of the draft. Again, the Devils final year took Nemec and handed on Shane Wright and Logan Cooley largely because they were space at centre with Jack Hughes and Nico Hischier. It occurs most regularly.
Drafting for want has long been taboo within the NHL because gamers within the draft were to date away from contributing to your team, and there became once no methodology of inspiring what your team will be taught about admire once those drafted gamers near. But that, too, is plot much less correct than it at likelihood of be. Gamers are transitioning from being draft-eligible to being within the NHL, especially on the quit of the draft, very rapid. Reinbacher is at most a year away from taking part in in Montreal. Some specialise in he could perchance well well also play within the NHL straight away, and Reinbacher himself is launch to any scenario, including taking part in within the AHL as Nemec did this season.
But I’d argue that blindly drafting the finest participant available whereas ignoring your wants and also ignoring whether you contain got got already received that profile of participant is silly. Michkov, in my be taught about, goes to achieve quite a lot of targets within the NHL. I also in point of truth feel that methodology about Cole Caufield. Michkov, in my be taught about, goes to pressure coaches bonkers with his indifference when taking part in with out the puck. I also in point of truth feel that methodology, to about a diploma, about Caufield. You should undercover agent the associated payment of the targets Caufield creates out of nothing and settle for to live with the inefficiencies in other areas of his game. But can you stay with two of those gamers? Can you fetch with two of those gamers? I don’t mediate you should perchance well well presumably.
But can you fetch with any individual admire Reinbacher? I don’t know. But what I make know is in uncover to fetch, you wish any individual admire what the Canadiens in point of truth feel Reinbacher will change into.
In 2022-23, Reinbacher became once taking part in for Kloten at age 17 within the second division in Switzerland. He most regularly had zero probability of being drafted, let by myself drafted at No. 5, taking part in in that division. But Kloten won the division and earned promotion to the quit league in Switzerland in a year where that league became once staunch about as staunch as it’s ever been. They elevated the amount of imports per team from four to 6, they’d an influx of imports fleeing the KHL, and Reinbacher peaceable thrived.
But perchance extra fundamental is that in accordance to his coach, Reinbacher at 17 became once a huge cause Kloten became once within the quit division to launch with.
“He became once taking part in within the second league and he made steps all year in that first year with us in that second league, and he became once a huge cause that we ended up going up,” Jeff Tomlinson acknowledged. “That’s no longer simple to make in Switzerland. He became once the fellow that staunch ran with it. Without him, we would contain had distress getting up. I indicate, he became once a bigger difference maker for us defensively and transferring the puck. We knew going into this season, the team, all of us knew that he became once going to be in our high four going into the season. We believed he became once going to be in our high four thanks to how he staunch replied to every explain. And , he’s a huge diminutive one. He skates Effectively, why no longer, appropriate? Why no longer give it to him?”
Responding to every explain became once a huge thing for Tomlinson. Early within the season, no longer pondering Reinbacher would gain a wager to play on the flexibility play, cases dictated that he needed to play a game on Kloten’s second energy play unit. He never left.
“He perceived to surprise us at every offensive characteristic we gave him,” Tomlinson acknowledged. “We didn’t launch off with him on the flexibility play before all the pieces of the season. That wasn’t the understanding. It became once staunch to gain him at likelihood of taking part in within the league and work with him. And then he received the chance, and he took it in one game. You realize, some guys favor 10 games or 20 games and they peaceable state, coach, I didn’t gain a wager.
“But David always met that expectation that we had for him, and exceeded it. I didn’t seek data from him to cease on the flexibility play all year, but he did.”
That ability to exceed expectations comes from Reinbacher’s nature.
“I mediate he’s staunch a relaxed diminutive one and he goes about it commerce-admire,” Tomlinson acknowledged. “Definite, all of us gain frustrated, and he does, too. On the other hand it’s no longer at a level where it blocks him. He strikes on. He tends to in point of truth work on the things that he needs to after discover because he’s no longer happy with it. So he’ll intention finish it perchance to a diverse level.
“But he’s staunch in point of truth tranquil within the head and he’s extra, how make I state it, he’s no longer stressful in his head. And I mediate that that’s a really huge quality for him. He’s ready to slack the sport down accessible and he’s ready to course of things honest a diminutive clearer, I mediate. That became once a huge thing for him.”
Processing the sport is what this Canadiens administration values extra than perchance the relaxation.
Montreal native and hockey data skilled Thibaud Chatel works broadly with teams in Switzerland monitoring data and providing detailed analytics to his customers and subscribers. His carrier, NL Ice Data, tracked 22 of Reinbacher’s games with Kloten, and came to the next conclusion.
“To gain deeper, we in fact contain a prospects mannequin, which appears to be like at every participant from 16 to 22 and projects their means profession (till) they reach 30 years archaic. On this one, Reinbacher became once merely the second-simplest participant within the draft gradual (Connor) Bedard, with a 52 p.c probability of being an ‘Elite’ (high 10 p.c) participant within the league on moderate for the length of the subsequent decade.”
There is a sound argument to be made that if the Canadiens weren’t going to draft Michkov, they’ll deserve to contain traded down and added some label. Hughes acknowledged 5 – 6 teams were calling him for the decide, but they didn’t undercover agent a label in making that commerce when when put next with the associated payment they seen in Reinbacher.
Brière acknowledged they were shopping for the methodology to bound as much as make certain they received Michkov.
“To contain a talent of his caliber, we didn’t mediate he could perchance well well be available at seven. So we looked at diverse opportunities to intention finish a stare upon to bound up,” he acknowledged. “The payment of picks on the day of a draft, for some cause, perceived to head up very, very excessive. So we weren’t ready to gain finish to any of the different picks in entrance of us. So we staunch roughly waited and it roughly fell into our lap. So for us, it became once a really easy decision.”
The explain for the Canadiens is trading all the vogue down to No. 7 meant they would no longer be ready to draft Reinbacher, because he became once most regularly guaranteed to head to the Coyotes at No. 6 if he were available. That’s how badly they major this guy.
The Canadiens will possible be depraved. Maybe drafting Reinbacher became once a mistake. But Hughes known as him a “diamond within the rough,” any individual they viewed as having tons of upside as well to positional label, any individual who will play tons of minutes for the Canadiens for a really very long time.
The Canadiens label gamers that will form in a playoff ambiance, and they undercover agent that in Reinbacher.
They’re, in essence, making a wager on themselves and their ability to mediate prospects, and they’re doing it for a second year in a row within the face of large public stress to draft any individual else.
And when Reinbacher became once requested if he became once familiar with any of the young defencemen within the Canadiens’ machine, his eyes without extend lit up and he smiled.
“Yeah, for determined. Lane Hutson,” Reinbacher acknowledged. “He made a nice dangle on the field championships against us. I’m capable of’t wait to be taught about him.”
Reinbacher’s profile would gain him a supreme partner for Hutson someday, something Logan Mailloux or Justin Barron — the 2 high young appropriate-shot defencemen within the pipeline — wouldn’t be.
“It could perchance well well be wonderful to play with him,” Reinbacher acknowledged. “I dispute he’s left-handed, so a supreme pair.”
Drafting and team constructing are diverse? Now no longer so determined. Hughes denied that this decide became once extra in step with team constructing than drafting, and I’m no longer so determined.
But I’m also no longer so determined that team constructing ought to peaceable no longer be a ingredient in drafting, both.
(Photo: Dave Sandford / NHLI thru Getty Photos)